People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Pizza is really good, especially for a small town spot! I've only tried the pepperoni and cheese but It's a great crispy texture and good ratio of ingredients. The sauce is slightly sweeter which isn't my preferred flavor but overall it's definitely very good! ”
“ DELICIOUS! We have wanted to try for sometime now...however, we live in Westerville. But today!! today! ~ after running errands and a grocery pick up in Heath... it timed out in our favor. XXL Pep and their 12" Lake House Laker Sub! Both were hot and fresh and they made it alll the way to Westerville without my usual complimentary corners for picking up dinner! True testament of how excited we were to try! We'll be back for sure!!! ”
“ Amazing pizza and sub! Very crispy . If you like thin crust this is the place for you. I found a replacement for Lil Siscilys :) they use lots of pepperonis on their pizza and don't skimp on the sauce . The sub was HUGE and so flavorful. The Lakehouse sub is the way to go. Friendly service and very clean place ! If you want to dine in there is a small dining area . Will be a repeat customer for sure ! ”
“ This is my fave pizza around! I am in Johnstown and of course we have many options but I prefer driving the extra few min to Alexandria for this delicious pizza! Also don't sleep on the ice cream place next door by the same owner! Sooo good! ”
“ Really good tavern cut style pizza with generous toppings. Give it a try and you won't be disappointed. ”
“ In my opinion this is the best pizza around. We live in Johnstown and drive past several other pizza places to go here ”
“ I have enjoyed everything on the menu! Usually gets done really quick, and you can pick it up, get it delivered or eat inside. ”
“ This pizza parlor is located in the old Drummies location. The restaurant is clean and the staff is friendly. I ordered an "All the Way"pizza. It was excellent! The toppings were plentiful and bottom of the pizza had a little crunch to it. As I am fan big fan of pepperoni pizza as well, I will be ordering a pepperoni next time. I highly recommend trying this place. ”
About
Johnstons LakeHouse pizza
Welcome to Johnstons LakeHouse Pizza, a charming gem nestled in the heart of Alexandria, Ohio. Located at 51 N Liberty St, this delightful eatery promises to satisfy your pizza cravings with its unique offerings.
Johnstons LakeHouse Pizza has quickly earned a reputation for its delicious, crispy crust and generous toppings. Customers rave about the tavern cut style pizza that features a harmonious blend of flavors and textures. Courtney F. notes the "great crispy texture" and the well-portioned ingredients in her pepperoni and cheese pie, while others echo the sentiment with mentions of the perfect balance of sauce and toppings.
One standout highlight is their Lake House Laker Sub. Ronda D. describes it as "HUGE and flavorful," a must-try for anyone looking to complement their pizza with a hearty sandwich option. The friendly service and clean ambiance further enhance the dining experience, whether you choose to dine in or take your meal to go.
The insights from visitors reveal a consistent theme: quality and care in every bite. Cheryl C. traveled from Westerville just to experience this culinary haven, and Amanda K. prefers the drive from Johnstown over local alternatives, highlighting the high esteem in which Johnstons LakeHouse Pizza is held.
And for those with a sweet tooth, don’t forget to stop by the ice cream shop next door, also owned by the same proprietor—a perfect way to round off a delightful meal.
Whether you're a local or just passing through, Johnstons LakeHouse Pizza is a must-visit destination where flavor meets hospitality. Experience the allure of their crispy pizzas, delicious subs, and the warmth of a quaint small-town pizzeria. Trust us, you won’t be disappointed!
Book a table